Newtown, CT / 85 DAYS ON MARKET

34 West StreetNewtown, CT 06470

Asking price$1,300,000Active

Our Take

34 West Street in Newtown sits on 6.7 acres, a half-mile from the town center and bordering Castle Hill Farm. The property includes six bedrooms, five bathrooms, and a private in-law apartment. Its grounds feature mature landscaping, fruit trees, rose gardens, and flowering plantings. An attached barn has three horse stalls and three fenced paddocks. A cobblestone bridge spans a waterfall on the grounds.

34 West Street — photo 1
1 / 27

Estimated buyer rebate

Buy with Cress and Save $9,750 on brokerage fees*

When you buy with Cress, we give you back a portion of the brokerage commission we receive.

See how the commission rebate works ↗

*Estimate assumes a 2.5% buyer-agent commission and a 30% rebate. Actual savings depend on final purchase price and commission received.

(212) 203-5251 george@cress.coContact form →

At a glance

Active · MLS #24186258
Bedrooms
6
BathroomsBaths
4 full / 1 half
Square feet
5,182
Year built
1954
Acres
6.7
Property taxes
$12,210

July 2025-June 2026

What stands out

  • Six bedrooms and five bathrooms
  • Private in-law apartment
  • Half-mile from the town center
  • Borders Castle Hill Farm
  • Attached barn with three horse stalls
  • Three fenced paddocks
  • Fruit trees and rose gardens
  • Cobblestone bridge spanning a waterfall
Read the full listing description

A rare opportunity to own a private estate in the heart of Newtown. Set on 6.7 beautifully manicured acres just a half-mile from the town center, this exceptional property offers 5,794 square feet of living space, including 6 bedrooms, 5 bathrooms, and a private in-law apartment. Bordering Castle Hill Farm, the property provides a peaceful country setting with the convenience of nearby shops, restaurants, and community amenities. Equestrian enthusiasts will appreciate the attached barn with 3 horse stalls and 3 fenced paddocks, making this a unique in-town horse property. The stunning grounds feature mature landscaping, fruit trees, rose gardens, and an array of flowering plantings. A handcrafted cobblestone bridge spans a picturesque waterfall, creating a truly enchanting setting unlike any other. Whether you're seeking multi-generational living, an equestrian retreat, or simply a one-of-a-kind property with acreage close to town, this remarkable estate offers endless possibilities. Properties combining this level of privacy, acreage, and convenience rarely become available. Don't miss the chance to make this extraordinary Newtown property your own.

Schools

Elementary
Per Board of Ed
Middle
Per Board of Ed
High
Newtown

Schools as reported by SmartMLS. Confirm attendance assignments with the district.

A closer look at the location

Open Google Maps ↗

34 West Street, Newtown, CT 06470

Price history

DateEventPrice
Originally listed$1,300,000

Intermediate price changes and previous listings may not be included.

Could this be your next home?

Let’s talk about the property—and what working with Cress could save you.

Inquire about this property →

*Estimate: $1,300,000 asking price × assumed 2.5% buyer-agent commission × 30% rebate = $9,750. Actual savings depend on the final purchase price and commission Cress receives. The assumed commission is not a representation of this listing's offered compensation.

Listed by Scalzo Real Estate · (203) 790-7077

Derek Spencer

SmartMLS · Listing #24186258 · Active

Listing data checked: Sep 17, 2026, 7:06 PM EDT.

Listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Cress commentary is separate from the MLS listing description. Contact Cress about a correction.

For personal, noncommercial use to identify properties you may be interested in purchasing.