36 Mortimer Street

New Canaan, CT 06840

$1,770,000Sold
3
beds
2.5
baths
2,170
SF

Our Take

36 Mortimer Street is a 1924 Colonial with three bedrooms and two full and one half bath. The home is described as in town, with access to the village, train, shops, and restaurants just minutes away. Interior features include inviting living spaces, thoughtful updates, and natural light throughout. Outside, the private backyard is landscaped and arranged for relaxing and entertaining. A detached garage provides additional space and flexibility, including use as a home office or party barn.

The two-story, wood-shingled Colonial at 36 Mortimer Street dates to about 1924, with a detached garage dated to about 1925. The house stands on a 0.14-acre lot along Mortimer Street, part of Prospect Heights, a development begun in 1915 by Frank B. Gurley of Stamford. The street was named for Gladys Mortimer, secretary to Judge James E. Brinckerhoff, one of Gurley’s legal advisers. A permit for additions and alterations was issued in September 2008.

Research note: The Town of New Canaan Assessor assigns 1924 to the house and 1925 to the garage; original construction records were not located. The Connecticut state survey identifies Colonial Revival styling, but the underlying survey pages were not retrieved. The original owner, architect and builder remain unidentified. The 2008 permit does not establish which alterations were completed.

Property Details

Listing Facts

Acres
0.14
Year built
1924
Taxes (July 2026-June 2027)
$14,117 (July 2026-June 2027)
Price/SF
$816
Days on Market
30 Days
MLS number
24179113

Highlights

  • In-town Colonial with character and convenience
  • Three bedrooms and two-and-a-half baths
  • Natural light throughout the home
  • Private landscaped backyard for relaxing and entertaining
  • Detached garage with home office or party barn use
Read the full listing description

Charming in-town Colonial offering the perfect blend of character, comfort and convenience. This beautifully updated 3-bedroom, 2 1/2 bath home is just minutes to the village, train, shops and restaurants. Filled with warmth and charm, the home features inviting living spaces, thoughtful updates and wonderful natural light throughout. The private backyard is a true gem beautifully landscaped, space for relaxing and entertaining. A detached garage provides valuable additional space and flexibility; home office, party barn. Combining charm, convenience and outdoor beauty, this home is a wonderful opportunity in a sought-after neighborhood.

Schools

Elementary
South
Middle
Saxe Middle
High
New Canaan

School assignments as reported by SmartMLS.

Price History

DateEventPrice
Sold$1,770,000
Listed$1,795,000

Listing Agent

Brown Harris Stevens · (203) 966-7800
Donna Socci · (203) 644-5028

Building permit history

How we compile this →

Permit records document renovation activity at this property.

2026
Renovation/RemodelRenovation

Mold remediation leading to a bathroom renovation (no plumbing or electrical change). Mold remediation leading to a basement waterproofing system (already existing, not functioning properly). Mold remediation leading to a garage renovation (no plumbing or electrical change).

Issued date
PermitBP-26-263
Declared project cost$48,000

Interpretation note: This matched record set reflects only the municipal data currently imported; it is not a claim that no other work occurred.

How we compile this. The source is New Canaan municipal permit records. These records are imported periodically and are not a live feed from the town. A permit’s presence does not, by itself, confirm that work was completed or passed final inspection. Dates shown are issue dates unless identified otherwise. Descriptions may be lightly edited for readability without changing material details. Dollar amounts are town-reported project costs or permit valuations, not estimates of the property’s market value.

Map

36 Mortimer Street, New Canaan, CT 06840

Homes for Sale in New Canaan ↗

Nearby Properties for Sale

Homes for Sale in New Canaan ↗

Interested in a property like this?

Cress can help you understand the market and find currently available homes.

Contact Cress →

SmartMLS · Listing #24179113 · Closed

Listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Cress commentary is separate from the MLS listing description. Contact Cress about a correction.

For personal, noncommercial use to identify properties you may be interested in purchasing.