58 Seminary Street

New Canaan, CT 06840

$1,462,500Sold
4
beds
3
baths
2,866
SF

Our Take

58 Seminary Street is an 1858 New Canaan home with four bedrooms and three full baths on 0.23 acres. The house has been restored and expanded, with a master suite, office, three additional bedrooms, and a main level organized around living, dining, kitchen, and family spaces. A coffered-ceiling family room includes a fireplace and glass doors to the outside. The property also includes a mud room, one-car detached garage, generator, private patio, and backyard.

At 58 Seminary Street, the Watts Comstock House dates to about 1858. The north-facing, two-story dwelling has a five-bay front, clapboard siding, and a stone foundation. A small porch shelters its central entrance, where a paneled wood door is topped by a three-light transom. Additions extend east and south from the saltbox-form house. A separate twentieth-century garage stands behind it.

Research note: The Connecticut State Historic Preservation Office’s nomination distinguishes this house from the Baptist Minister’s Residence at 66 Seminary Street. The New Canaan Museum & Historical Society uses the Watts Comstock name for 66 Seminary Street; the ministerial and family history in that account has not been established for 58 Seminary Street. The National Park Service recorded a district eligibility determination following owner objections on July 19, 2024, rather than a listing. The reported state and local designation flags were not independently confirmed at parcel level.

Property Details

Listing Facts

Acres
0.23
Year built
1858
Taxes (July 2022-June 2023)
$10,538 (July 2022-June 2023)
Price/SF
$510
Days on Market
97 Days
MLS number
170531873

Highlights

  • Restored and expanded with modern amenities
  • Master suite with full bath and office
  • Three additional bedrooms and full bath
  • Family room with coffered ceilings and fireplace
  • Glass doors connect the family room outdoors
  • Mud room and one-car detached garage
  • Generator, private patio, and backyard
Read the full listing description

A PLACE OF BOUNDLESS WARMTH & CLASSIC CHARM -Welcome home to this exceptional country home located in the picuresque town of New Canaan minutes walk to the charming Village Center and train station. The home has been beautifully restored and expanded that provides modern day amenities with flawless integration. The home comprises a master suite with full bath and large office, 3 additional bedrooms and bath. The main level offers a formal living room, dining combined fully equippd kitchen, a large family room with coffered ceilings, fire place, wall of glass doors to the outside and circular stairway to 2nd floor office, full bath. Additionally there is a mud room, 1 car detached garage, generator, private patio and back yard.

Schools

Elementary
West
Middle
Saxe Middle
High
New Canaan

School assignments as reported by SmartMLS.

Price History

DateEventPrice
Sold$1,462,500
Listed$1,525,000

Listing Agent

Silver Pine Real Estate
Shalini Madaras

Map

58 Seminary Street, New Canaan, CT 06840

Homes for Sale in New Canaan ↗

Nearby Properties for Sale

Homes for Sale in New Canaan ↗

Interested in a property like this?

Cress can help you understand the market and find currently available homes.

Contact Cress →

SmartMLS · Listing #170531873 · Closed

Listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Cress commentary is separate from the MLS listing description. Contact Cress about a correction.

For personal, noncommercial use to identify properties you may be interested in purchasing.