66 Seminary Street

New Canaan, CT 06840

$2,225,000Sold
3
beds
3.5
baths
2,300
SF

Our Take

66 Seminary is the Watts Comstock House, dating to circa 1872, with three bedrooms and three full and one half bath. The home has been restored and reimagined with new infrastructure while retaining original moldings and trim work. Its interior includes a kitchen with pantry, new bathrooms, 8-inch plank flooring, arched ceilings, oversized sashed windows, and a tiled room suited to a breakfast nook or home office. A two-story barn/studio and designed land and hardscapes add options for four-season living.

66 Seminary Street is an 1872 Second Empire house built by Watts Comstock as an intended home for New Canaan’s Baptist minister. Its mansard roof, gabled dormers and prominent corner tower give the small house a distinctive profile. The grounds also include a separate outbuilding dating to about 1890 and an early-twentieth-century picket fence.

Comstock, a founder of the First Baptist Society and the first president of the New Canaan First National Bank, deeded the property to his son Edwin in 1875. Edwin sold it to shoemaker James Fairty in 1879. The Fairty family retained it until 1951, when Dorothy Moore Burnham bought the house and moved in with her two sons. Burnham had served on the Board of Education and as third selectman. She also rescued early town officeholders’ records from disposal and gave them to the historical society.

Later, George McEvoy converted a barn garage into a pottery studio with a kiln, where he exhibited his work. He and Heidi McEvoy also hosted chamber-music performances in the house.

Research note: The Church Hill Historic District nomination identifies the house as the Baptist Minister’s Residence. The New Canaan Museum & Historical Society reports no record confirming clergy occupancy. The National Park Service determined the nominated district eligible on July 19, 2024, following owner objections; that action was not a National Register listing. State Register and local-district coverage for this parcel remain unconfirmed.

Property Details

Listing Facts

Acres
0.21
Year built
1872
Taxes (July 2025-June 2026)
$13,213 (July 2025-June 2026)
Price/SF
$967
Days on Market
93 Days
MLS number
24090280

Highlights

  • Circa-1872 Watts Comstock House
  • Three bedrooms and three-and-a-half baths
  • Kitchen with pantry and new bathrooms
  • Arched ceilings and oversized sashed windows
  • Tiled room for breakfast nook or home office
  • Two-story barn/studio
  • Mudroom, den, and full bath downstairs
  • Three bedrooms on the top floor
Read the full listing description

66 Seminary The Watts Comstock House (c. 1872) is a 3 BR 3 1/2 bath home in the heart of downtown New Canaan. Fully restored and lovingly reimagined for today's living this 2,300 sq ft home with large 2 story barn/studio offers all new infrastructure while maintaining the original charm and the rare moldings and trim work. Located in the heart of town and an ideal distance to the train station, shops, and restaurants on one of New Canaan's oldest streets, the house includes a gorgeous new gourmet kitchen with pantry, all new bathrooms, new 8" plank flooring-a nod to the original hardwoods. 9' arched ceilings and sashed oversized windows allow natural light to flood this elegant home. In addition to the kitchen, living and dining rooms the main floor also includes an artfully tiled room with marble and soapstone, perfect for a breakfast nook or home office. Downstairs a mudroom leads to the cozy den with full bath and large laundry room. The top floor is complete with three airy sunlit BRs. Beautifully designed land and hardscapes offer myriad opportunity for 4 season living. Barn is easily converted to a garage and/or connected to heat and plumbing. Don't miss this unique opportunity to be a part of New Canaan history!

Schools

Elementary
West
Middle
Saxe Middle
High
New Canaan

School assignments as reported by SmartMLS.

Price History

DateEventPrice
Sold$2,225,000
Listed$2,395,000
Sold$1,100,000
Listed$1,395,000

Listing Agent

Coldwell Banker Realty · (203) 966-3737
Marsha Charles · (203) 904-4663

Building permit history

How we compile this →

Permit records document renovation activity at this property.

2026
Renovation/RemodelRenovation

Bathroom in existing pool house.

Issued date
PermitBP-26-148
Declared project cost$80,000
New Deck

Description not provided by town.

Issued date
PermitBP-26-92
Declared project cost$80,000
Pool

Construction of a shotcrete 15' x 38' inground swimming pool. Adding 100 square feet of patio and constructing retaining walls.

Issued date
PermitBP-26-44
Declared project cost$94,000
2024
Revision

Enclose the existing covered porch and the deck above the covered porch.

Issued date
PermitBPR-24-30
Declared project cost$95,000

Interpretation note: This matched record set reflects only the municipal data currently imported; it is not a claim that no other work occurred.

How we compile this. The source is New Canaan municipal permit records. These records are imported periodically and are not a live feed from the town. A permit’s presence does not, by itself, confirm that work was completed or passed final inspection. Dates shown are issue dates unless identified otherwise. Descriptions may be lightly edited for readability without changing material details. Dollar amounts are town-reported project costs or permit valuations, not estimates of the property’s market value.

Map

66 Seminary Street, New Canaan, CT 06840

Homes for Sale in New Canaan ↗

Nearby Properties for Sale

Homes for Sale in New Canaan ↗

Interested in a property like this?

Cress can help you understand the market and find currently available homes.

Contact Cress →

SmartMLS · Listing #24090280 · Closed

Listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Cress commentary is separate from the MLS listing description. Contact Cress about a correction.

For personal, noncommercial use to identify properties you may be interested in purchasing.