57 Evergreen Avenue

Westport, CT 06880

$3,950,000Sold
6
beds
7
baths
6,000
SF

Our Take

57 Evergreen Avenue is a 1920 Dutch Colonial that has been torn down to the studs and rebuilt, with two properties combined into one in-town setting on 1.17 acres. The home centers on a chef’s kitchen and family room with accordion glass doors opening to a patio and in-ground pool. Other features include German-imported windows and doors, a primary suite with vaulted ceiling, spa bath, two walk-in closets and a pool-facing balcony, plus an accessory dwelling unit and smart-home features.

Property Details

Listing Facts

Acres
1.17
Year built
1920
Taxes (July 2024-June 2025)
$18,086 (July 2024-June 2025)
Price/SF
$658
Days on Market
27 Days
MLS number
24056174

Highlights

  • Rebuilt 1920 Dutch Colonial on 1.17 acres
  • Chef’s kitchen with a large island
  • Accordion glass doors open to patio and pool
  • Windows and doors imported from Germany
  • Primary suite with vaulted ceiling and spa bath
  • Primary balcony overlooking the pool
  • Accessory dwelling unit for guests or household members
  • Smart-home features
Read the full listing description

Walk to downtown shops and restaurants from this stunning, reimagined, & rebuilt 1920 Dutch colonial home, situated on a spacious 1.17-acre in-town property.This is truly a work of art, as 2 properties have been seamlessly combined into one, creating a private oasis set way back from the road.Upon entering the home, you will be captivated by the meticulous attention to detail & the perfect blend of modern amenities and old-world charm.The entire home has been torn down to the studs & rebuilt, ensuring that every aspect meets the highest standards of quality & craftsmanship. The heart of this home is the gorgeous chef's kitchen, complete w/large island & family room that features accordion glass doors leading to a breathtaking patio w/inground pool, perfect for enjoying the outdoors & entertaining guests. Windows & doors throughout the home, imported from Germany, add an element of sophistication & elegance.Not only are they aesthetically pleasing, but they are also multi-functional, allowing for an abundance of natural light & fresh air to fill the space. The 6000 Sq ft home boasts high-end details & finishes on four levels.5/6 bedrooms & 6 full and 2 half baths incl a TO-DIE-FOR Primary Suite w/vaulted ceiling, stunning spa bath, 2 walk-in closets & a balcony overlooking the pool. There is plenty of room for everyone to have their own private retreat. The property includes an Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU), ideal for guests, in-laws, or a live-in nanny. Smart home!

Schools

Elementary
Saugatuck
Middle
Bedford
High
Staples

School assignments as reported by SmartMLS.

Price History

DateEventPrice
Sold$3,950,000
Listed$3,985,000

Listing Agent

Compass Connecticut, LLC
Hyleri Katzenberg

Building permit history

How we compile this →

Records show a cluster of renovation and addition activity.

2026
Residential Fuel TankMechanical

1000-gallon underground propane tank with a line in a trench to the house and pool heater.

Issued date
PermitBLD-2026-00841
2025
Residential Addition and AlterationAddition

Two additions: a garage with a suite above and a two-story family room addition with a suite above. One-story addition for a great room and miscellaneous interior renovations. Foundation only.

Issued date
PermitBLD-2025-02203
2024
Residential ElectricElectrical

Wire the accessory dwelling unit (ADU) over the garage, including the kitchen, bathroom, living room, bedroom, and 3-car garage.

Issued date
PermitBLD-2023-02688
Residential PlumbingPlumbing

Rough and install a kitchenette and bathroom with a toilet, sink, and tub.

Issued date
PermitBLD-2023-02690
Residential HVACMechanical

Install 2 propane-fired furnaces with all related ductwork.

Issued date
PermitBLD-2023-02684
Residential HVACMechanical

Install a propane furnace and air conditioning with all related ductwork for an accessory dwelling unit (ADU).

Issued date
PermitBLD-2023-02689
Residential Upgrade

Amendment for new bathrooms and miscellaneous interior changes per revised drawings.

Issued date
PermitBLD-2024-00486
2023
Residential ElectricElectrical

Renovation of 5 bathrooms, 5 bedrooms, kitchen, living room, dining room, foyer, mud roo, finished basement and finished attic.

Issued date
PermitBLD-2023-02683
Residential AdditionAddition

Remove and replace the first bay of the existing garage and modify the roofline to accommodate a new accessory dwelling unit above.

Issued date
PermitBLD-2023-02687
Residential AdditionAddition

Renovations to existing dwelling: second-floor balcony off primary bedroom. Remove and replace existing study (new foundation—crawl); second-story addition for bathroom and closet. Amendment: new bathrooms and miscellaneous interior changes per revised drawings.

Issued date
PermitBLD-2023-02682
Residential PlumbingPlumbing

Description not provided by town.

Issued date
PermitBLD-2023-00720
Residential PlumbingPlumbing

Rough and install kitchen sink, dishwasher, refrigerator, hallway toilet and sink, 2 hose bibs, 2d floor bathrooms - 3 toilets, 3 shower/tub, sinks; gas line for furnace and fireplace.

Issued date
PermitBLD-2023-02685
Residential ElectricElectrical

Description not provided by town.

Issued date
PermitBLD-2023-00718
Residential AlterationRenovation

Miscellaneous interior renovations; install beams as per plans.

Issued date
PermitBLD-2023-00717
Residential HVACMechanical

Description not provided by town.

Issued date
PermitBLD-2023-00719

Interpretation note: A dense sequence can suggest coordinated work, but permit issue dates do not establish completion and separate town records are not automatically combined.

How we compile this. The source is Westport municipal permit records. These records are imported periodically and are not a live feed from the town. A permit’s presence does not, by itself, confirm that work was completed or passed final inspection. Dates shown are issue dates unless identified otherwise. Descriptions may be lightly edited for readability without changing material details. Dollar amounts are town-reported project costs or permit valuations, not estimates of the property’s market value.

Map

57 Evergreen Avenue, Westport, CT 06880

Homes for Sale in Westport ↗

Nearby Properties for Sale

Homes for Sale in Westport ↗

Interested in a property like this?

Cress can help you understand the market and find currently available homes.

Contact Cress →

SmartMLS · Listing #24056174 · Closed

Listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Cress commentary is separate from the MLS listing description. Contact Cress about a correction.

For personal, noncommercial use to identify properties you may be interested in purchasing.