44 Compo Mill Cove

Westport, CT 06880

$3,200,000Sold
4
beds
1.5
baths
1,593
SF

Our Take

44 Compo Mill Cove is a seasonal four-bedroom beach house on a private, gated setting at the point of Compo Mill Cove, with panoramic views of Long Island Sound and Mill Cove. The property has a private sandy beach with 150 feet of frontage, plus a teak boardwalk, wrap-around porch, and stone patio. Inside are a classic beach-house wooden interior and cozy stone fireplace. The setting also supports kayaking, paddle boarding, and sailing, while groceries and packages can be delivered to the door.

44 Compo Mill Cove, known as Gallagher Cottage, is a bungalow built about 1917 and a contributing house in the Mill Cove Historic District. The district developed as a community of seasonal cottages reached by footpath and boardwalk across the outlet of Sherwood Millpond.

The one-and-a-half-story house has a deep porch beneath its side-gabled roof, a broad shed dormer facing Long Island Sound, and exposed rafter ends. A large stone fireplace is another defining feature.

After purchasing the property in 2022, Anne and Lance Lonergan undertook a rehabilitation that raised the house for coastal resilience while retaining the porch, dormer, and characteristic roof form. Cedar roofing replaced asphalt shingles. The Westport Historic District Commission recognized the work with a 2026 Rehabilitation Preservation Award, honoring a project that adapted the shoreline house while preserving its architectural character.

Research note: The National Register nomination dates the principal bungalow to approximately 1917; other sources cite 1910. It separately identifies an associated cottage dating to approximately 1905. That smaller building's present survival and its relationship to the available boathouse identification remain unconfirmed.

Property Details

Listing Facts

Acres
0.64
Year built
1910
Taxes (July 2022-June 2023)
$34,902 (July 2022-June 2023)
Price/SF
$2,009
Days on Market
78 Days
MLS number
170470504

Highlights

  • Panoramic Long Island Sound and Mill Cove views
  • Private sandy beach with 150 feet of frontage
  • Teak boardwalk leading to the house
  • Wrap-around porch and stone patio
  • Classic beach-house interior and stone fireplace
  • Seasonal four-bedroom home
  • Kayaking, paddle boarding, and sailing
  • Groceries and packages delivered to the door
Read the full listing description

Exquisite, private, and gated beach on the point of Compo Mill Cove an exclusive peninsula in the heart of Westport! This property is surrounded by panoramic water views of beautiful Long Island Sound and Mill Cove. Compo Mill Cove is a treasured peninsula, where nature surrounds you and quietly fills the air. Take in the abundant bird and sea life and find peace on the water while kayaking, paddle boarding or sailing. The teak boardwalk leads you to 44 Compo Mill Cove, one of the most treasured properties in Westport, on your own private beach. An authentic seasonal 4-bedroom home built in 1917 with a classic beach house wooden interior and a cozy stone fireplace. A wrap-around porch and stone patio allow for outdoor living and plenty of room for entertainment all summer long while enjoying the 150 feet of private sandy beach frontage. 44 Compo Cove is the oldest original house remaining. Secluded location, yet groceries and packages can be conveniently delivered to your door. Own the entire point by purchasing with 48 Compo Mill Cove and or 42 Compo Mill Cove . Enjoy this wonderful seasonal home or take the opportunity to transform into a year-round home. A one-of-a-kind chance to own a piece of Westport history!

Schools

Elementary
Greens Farms
Middle
Bedford
High
Staples

School assignments as reported by SmartMLS.

Price History

DateEventPrice
Sold$3,200,000
Listed$3,295,000

Listing Agent

William Raveis Real Estate
Leslie Clarke

Building permit history

How we compile this →

Records show a cluster of renovation and addition activity.

2024
Residential ElectricElectrical

Rough and complete electrical work per plan, including supply / install 24kw liquid propane generator.

Issued date
PermitBLD-2023-02326
Residential Service

CRS #16662428 – 200 amp underground service.

Issued date
PermitBLD-2024-01570
Residential PlumbingPlumbing

Re-rough waste and water, and set all fixtures as per plans on file. Gas piping for stove, 2 furnaces, tankless water heater, generator, fireplace, and grill.

Issued date
PermitBLD-2023-02327
Residential HVACMechanical

Install 2 high-efficiency gas furnaces with AC coils, 2 condensing units, 3 exhaust fans, 1 electric resistance heater for kitchen makeup air, 1 dryer vent, 1 ERV, and 2 evaporative humidifiers.

Issued date
PermitBLD-2023-02329
Residential Fuel TankMechanical

Bury a 1000 gallon underground propane tank, strap it to concrete blocks for anti-float requirements, run a line in a trench to the house, and pipe out to the generator.

Issued date
PermitBLD-2024-00746
Residential AlarmFire protection

Security / fire / carbon monoxide / environmental alarm system: 1 panel, 2 keypads, 1 siren, 3 doors contacted, 1 motion sensor, 4 smoke detectors, 2 combo CO / smoke detectors, 2 heat detectors, 1 low tmp sensory, 2 flood sensors.

Issued date
PermitBLD-2024-00325
2023
Residential Service

CRS #14521928: Supply and install 200 amp underground temporary service per code.

Issued date
PermitBLD-2023-02328
Residential Addition and AlterationAddition

Raise existing house on piles, 2 one story additions for mech. Room, laundry, powder room, and closet. Second floor dormer addition for bathroom. Interior renovations, deck and covered porch additons. Stairs to grade.

Issued date
PermitBLD-2023-02325
2019
Residential AlterationRenovation

Miscellaneous interior renovations to remove a non-bearing wall. Enclose the existing covered porch.

Issued date
PermitBLD-2019-85095
Residential ElectricalElectrical

Renovation of laundry area and new sliding doors.

Issued date
PermitBLD-2019-85095-01
Residential PlumbingPlumbing

Re-rough plumbing for a washing machine on the first floor.

Issued date
PermitBLD-2019-85095-02
2017
Residential ElectricalElectrical

Relocate cables in the way of new dormers.

Issued date
PermitBLD-2017-82405-01
Residential AdditionAddition

Second-floor addition for new dormers and miscellaneous structural renovations.

Issued date
PermitBLD-2017-82405
2016
Residential Tent

Install 1 46' x 35' dining/dancing tent with floor installed directly on grade, 1 20' x 30' catering tent with 90' x 10' connector, 66' x 66' contigency ceremony tent for event date 8-27-16, installation rated for 115 mph.

Issued date
PermitBLD-2016-81813

Interpretation note: A dense sequence can suggest coordinated work, but permit issue dates do not establish completion and separate town records are not automatically combined.

How we compile this. The source is Westport municipal permit records. These records are imported periodically and are not a live feed from the town. A permit’s presence does not, by itself, confirm that work was completed or passed final inspection. Dates shown are issue dates unless identified otherwise. Descriptions may be lightly edited for readability without changing material details. Dollar amounts are town-reported project costs or permit valuations, not estimates of the property’s market value.

Map

44 Compo Mill Cove, Westport, CT 06880

Homes for Sale in Westport ↗

Nearby Properties for Sale

Homes for Sale in Westport ↗

Interested in a property like this?

Cress can help you understand the market and find currently available homes.

Contact Cress →

SmartMLS · Listing #170470504 · Closed

Listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Cress commentary is separate from the MLS listing description. Contact Cress about a correction.

For personal, noncommercial use to identify properties you may be interested in purchasing.